A controversy in a Michigan middle school has been resolved, but questions still remain over why a performing arts teacher was severely disciplined after allowing a student to play a marriage equality song in her classroom. The teacher, Susan Johnson, from Centennial Middle School, allowed the song after checking with the student to be sure it fit within the guidelines of the school district. However, the song offended at least one classmate, whose complaint eventually led to the teacher鈥檚 disciplinary action. Was the teacher merely defending a student鈥檚 freedom of speech, or was she in violation of district policy? The answer to that question appears to depend on who you ask.
The video offers an overview of freedom of speech in public schools.
鈥淪ame Love鈥 Subject of Controversy
According to , Johnson allowed a student in one of her eighth-grade performing arts classes to play the song 鈥淪ame Love鈥 by rapper Macklemore during class. Prior to granting permission, Johnson asked the student if the song contained any inappropriate language or references to violence. The student responded that it did not. In fact, 鈥淪ame Love鈥 is a song about marriage equality, depicting the life of a gay man from beginning to end. Some of the lyrics in the song include:
鈥淐an鈥檛 change, even if I tried鈥︹
鈥淣o freedom 鈥榯il we鈥檙e equal鈥︹
鈥淲e become so numb to what we鈥檙e saying鈥︹
鈥淚f I
